How we rate
Safety limits and label data come first. The least favourable applicable rule determines the verdict. Missing data limits the result.
Protein bar
One red portion value: not useful. A yellow value, collagen as main protein or palm fat: so-so. Polyols above the middle limit warn in yellow, not red.
- Calories: green ≤ 200 kcal, yellow ≤ 300 kcal, otherwise red.
- Protein: green ≥ 15 g, yellow ≥ 8 g, otherwise red.
- Sugar: green ≤ 5 g, yellow ≤ 12 g, otherwise red.
- Sugar alcohols: green ≤ 5 g, yellow ≤ 10 g, otherwise red.
- Fat: green ≤ 10 g, yellow ≤ 15 g, otherwise red.
- saturated fat: green ≤ 3 g, yellow ≤ 6 g, otherwise red.
- Fibre: green ≥ 5 g, yellow ≥ 2 g, otherwise red.
Daily amount, NRV, personal requirement according to DGE, BfR and EFSA
Above EFSA: not useful. Above BfR, below the personal requirement according to DGE or a yellow rule: so-so. Main substance and form count. Safety exceedances for all substances always count.
NRV: 15 % · Personal requirement according to DGE: 100 %.
Food
Bars count per fixed label portion. Other foods: FSA per 100 g. Two red FSA values: not useful, one: so-so. Protein and fibre follow EU rules.
- Fat: 3 g / 17.5 g
- saturated fat: 1.5 g / 5 g
- Sugar: 5 g / 22.5 g
- Salt: 0.3 g / 1.5 g
Protein: 12 / 20 % kcal · Fibre: 3 / 6 g.
My rules
zucker_in_nem: Sugar does not belong in a food supplement
suessstoff: Contains sweetener
zuckeralkohol: Sugar alcohols may have a laxative effect
Magnesium oxide: Poorly bioavailable form of magnesium
Zinc oxide: Poorly bioavailable form of zinc
Ethyl ester: Omega-3 as ethyl ester rather than triglyceride
Titanium dioxide|E171: Titanium dioxide (E171) is no longer authorised as a food additive in the EU
aminosaeure_spiking: Individual amino acids can inflate the protein value
hauptwirkstoff_unter15: Main active ingredient below 15 % NRV, barely an effective dose
ashwagandha|withania|ksm-66: The Federal Institute for Risk Assessment identifies health risks, including risks to the liver. Do not use during pregnancy or breastfeeding, or with liver disease. Use caution with thyroid medication. Banned in Denmark.
tryptophan: Do not take with antidepressants or other substances that affect serotonin without consulting a doctor.
Product comparison
Only values available for every product count. The first criterion carries the most points, with one point less for each subsequent criterion. The best value receives the points. If all values are equal, that criterion awards no points.
More points win. Products rated not useful come after assessable products with a higher verdict. Equal points mean no clear difference.
Conflicts with your details → Verdict level → Protein quality → Protein per 100 kcal → Sugar per portion → Calories per portion → Price per 20 g protein
Conflicts with your details → Verdict level → Share of NRV (up to 100% counts) → Form → Price per day → Number of additives
Sources: Food Information Regulation (Reg. 1169/2011, Annex XIII), German Nutrition Society (DGE) reference values, EFSA (DRV/UL), BfR proposed maximum levels 2021, FSA traffic lights, EU Reg. 1924/2006, WHO sugar limit. Some product data from Open Food Facts (ODbL).
Does not replace medical advice.
Start for free